Arcaro and Genell, Old Forge, PA

Arcaro and Genell in Old Forge, PA, stands as a beloved icon of authentic Italian cuisine, specializing in the legendary Old Forge pizza style that has captivated locals and visitors alike for decades. Nestled at 443 S Main St, this takeout-only restaurant offers an inviting, flavorful journey into traditional Italian fare, highlighted by their signature pizzas that are as rich in history as they are in taste.

Step into a world where every bite tells a story—the crust here is perfection itself: fresh, flaky, and boasting that memorable balance of crispy bottom and tender bread texture that pizza aficionados crave. Their White Pizza with Tomatoes and Onion offers a cheesy, luscious delight, while their Sweet Sauce Pizza selections, from the classic 6 Cut Tray to the tantalizing Hot Honey Pepperoni versions, provide a beautifully balanced sweetness and spice that dance across the palate.

Beyond pizza, Arcaro and Genell’s menu beckons with richly prepared appetizers like Golden Coconut Shrimp, creamy Fried Mozzarella, and the robustly flavored Minestra sautéed greens, each bite echoing the warmth and heart of great Italian cooking. Seafood lovers will be drawn to the Pesce options such as Shrimp Calabrese, where tender shrimp sautéed with peppers and potatoes exudes vibrant, comforting flavors, or their expertly broiled Haddock dishes that bring a buttery, lemon-kissed finish to the meal.

The atmosphere may be takeout-centric, but the spirit of community is palpable—owners and staff greet guests like family, with genuine warmth and an intimate knowledge of their loyal patrons. This hospitality perfectly complements the menu’s rich flavors, making each visit not just a meal, but a cherished experience. Customers consistently praise how the cheese stretches irresistibly and how the crust's delicate crispness keeps drawing them back—true testaments to the skill and passion poured into every pie.

Don't miss out on their homemade desserts, including the velvety Tiramisu and creamy Cannoli, which provide the perfect sweet note to conclude your feast. For those seeking a true taste of Old Forge, Arcaro and Genell is more than just a restaurant; it’s a culinary landmark that inspires fond memories and new traditions alike.

Whether you’re a long-time fan or discovering this Italian gem for the first time, the rich flavors, authentic recipes, and heartfelt service at Arcaro and Genell promise a deeply satisfying and unforgettable dining experience.